If you’re dreaming of a sunny escape to Mallorca but find yourself torn between Alcudia and Puerto Pollensa, you’re not alone. These two beloved towns on the island’s north coast each offer their own kind of magic—and choosing between them isn’t always easy.
Alcudia is steeped in history, with a beautifully preserved old town, Roman ruins, and a long sweep of golden beach that’s perfect for families. On the other hand, Puerto Pollensa has a laid-back, effortlessly elegant feel, with a crescent-shaped bay, pine-fringed promenade, and relaxed seaside charm that’s hard to resist.
Having explored both of these gems firsthand, I can tell you: there’s no wrong choice. But depending on the kind of holiday you're after—be it cultural discovery, beachside downtime, or active adventures—one might suit your style just a little more than the other.
In this guide, I’ll break down the key differences between Alcudia and Puerto Pollensa to help you decide which destination is the best fit for your next Mallorca getaway.
If you’re planning a trip to Mallorca and torn between staying in Alcúdia or Puerto Pollensa, you’re definitely not alone. We’ve spent time exploring both destinations and can honestly say—each has its own distinct charm and atmosphere. But depending on your travel style, one may be a better fit for your dream getaway.
Alcúdia is a town rich with history and atmosphere. Perched just above the sweeping bay that shares its name, this medieval gem is brimming with cobbled streets, ancient walls, and a surprisingly lively nightlife. Strolling through the old town feels like stepping back in time—with every turn revealing another layer of its storied past.
Puerto Pollensa, meanwhile, offers a slower, more serene pace of life. It may seem unassuming at first glance, but spend a little time here and you’ll quickly fall for its relaxed vibe, breathtaking coastal views, and easy access to nature. It’s become increasingly popular with visitors looking for scenic walks, family-friendly beaches, and a touch of old-school Mediterranean charm.
So, how do you decide where to stay in Mallorca—Alcúdia or Puerto Pollensa? That’s exactly why we created this side-by-side comparison. We’ve pulled together firsthand tips on everything from beaches and bars to things to do and places to eat, helping you make an informed choice that matches your holiday vision.
Nestled on the northeastern coast of Mallorca, Alcúdia is one of the island’s most family-friendly resorts—and for good reason. With more than 10km of golden sands, calm turquoise waters, and plenty of activities for all ages, it’s a beach lover’s dream.
But Alcúdia isn’t just about sun and sea. This town is steeped in history, believed to be the oldest settlement in the Balearics. Founded by the Phoenicians and later shaped by Roman and Moorish hands, Alcúdia wears its past proudly. Towering stone walls still enclose the old town, while ancient churches and Roman ruins are scattered throughout the area.
Held every Tuesday and Sunday morning, the Alcúdia market is one of the liveliest on the island. Located in the heart of the old town, it’s a wonderful place to browse for local produce, handmade crafts, clothing, and unique souvenirs.
There’s a true community feel here, with locals and tourists mingling among the stalls. It’s one of those authentic Mallorcan experiences that’s well worth your time.
Encircled by ancient city walls, Alcúdia’s old town is nothing short of enchanting. Lose yourself in its labyrinth of cobblestone lanes, where you’ll find hidden courtyards, quirky boutiques, and quaint cafés. Don’t miss the chance to walk along the ramparts for panoramic views over the town.
One standout stop is the Church of Sant Jaume, a stunning 13th-century structure with neo-Gothic design and intricate stained glass.
If you’re feeling active, Alcúdia is a brilliant base for exploring Mallorca’s natural beauty. One of our favourite spots is Mirador de la Victoria, a short hike that rewards you with jaw-dropping views over the Bay of Pollensa.
There’s even a 12th-century hermitage to explore at the top. And if you’ve worked up an appetite? There’s a charming restaurant nearby where you can refuel with local specialities.
You’ll be spoiled for choice when it comes to beaches in Alcúdia. The town’s main beach—Playa de Alcúdia—is one of the most impressive on the island, with miles of soft sand, gentle waves, and crystal-clear waters. It’s ideal for families, couples, or anyone looking to stretch out under the Mediterranean sun.
If you’re up for exploring, you’ll find plenty of quieter coves and smaller stretches of sand tucked along the coast too—perfect for those seeking a more peaceful beach day.
While it might not have the wild reputation of Magaluf, the nightlife in Alcúdia definitely has its own appeal. The town’s main nightlife hub, Dollar Street, is buzzing with bars and clubs where the party goes well into the night. If you’re up for dancing, head to 5 Glops—a fun and energetic Latin bar that always delivers good vibes and great music.
Prefer something more low-key? You’ll find plenty of relaxed spots to sip cocktails or enjoy a glass of local wine as the sun sets.
One of the joys of staying in Alcúdia is the incredible food. Whether you’re craving traditional Mallorcan fare or looking to try something a little more modern, there’s a fantastic mix of options. For a truly memorable meal, book a table at Restaurant Cellar C’an Costa. This family-run gem has been serving up local recipes for generations, and the setting—inside a beautifully preserved stone building—is as charming as the food is delicious.
From tapas bars to upscale dining, Alcúdia offers a culinary scene that perfectly complements its rich heritage and relaxed vibe.
Not far from Alcúdia town at the edge of the Tramuntana mountain range, sandwiched between Sa Pobla and the Port of Alcúdia, you’ll find Finca Alcudia Vell.
This charming holiday rental can host up to 16 guests in 8 double rooms and features its own vineyard, large outdoor pool, a wine cellar, terraces, and a barbeque area. It's a fantasttic venue for hosting a wedding or celebration event.
The property even has its own private hiking trails linking it to Sa Pobla and Puerto de Alcúdia, meaning you’re never far from some of the north of the island’s best destinations.
Tucked along the sweeping curve of Pollensa Bay, Puerto Pollensa is the kind of place that quietly works its way into your heart. It’s not flashy or overdeveloped—just effortlessly beautiful. With its mountain backdrop, golden beaches, and a calm, pine-fringed promenade, this charming seaside town is one of those rare spots where the pace of life slows down in all the right ways.
Having spent time here, I can completely understand why so many travellers—myself included—return again and again. There’s a softness to Puerto Pollensa, a certain serenity, that makes it feel like a true retreat. And while the relaxed atmosphere might be what initially draws you in, it’s the little details—sunset walks along the seafront, the clink of glasses at a beachside café, the sound of the waves gently brushing the shore—that really stay with you.
Funnily enough, Agatha Christie once found inspiration here too. She penned her story Problems at Pollensa Bay while visiting, clearly moved by the landscape and its peaceful rhythm. Don’t worry though—unlike her characters, you're unlikely to run into any trouble during your stay!
One of my most memorable adventures in Puerto Pollensa was the bike ride to Cap de Formentor—and if you're up for a little challenge, I can’t recommend it enough. The route winds its way through rugged cliffs, fragrant pine forests, and postcard-perfect viewpoints, all the way to the northernmost tip of Mallorca.
The ride takes about an hour and a quarter from town if you follow the Ma-2210, and while it’s a bit of a workout, the payoff is huge. When you finally reach the iconic lighthouse, perched above crashing waves and surrounded by sweeping sea views, it feels like you’ve cycled straight into a travel brochure. And yes, there’s a cosy little café at the top—perfect for refuelling with a cold drink or light bite as you soak in the vistas.
One of the loveliest things to do in Puerto Pollensa is also one of the simplest—strolling along the Pine Walk. Whether it's early morning with a takeaway coffee in hand, or late evening as the sky melts into gold and lilac, this peaceful promenade has a magic of its own.
Lined with fragrant pine trees and flanked by sparkling sea on one side and charming villas on the other, it’s the perfect place to pause, unwind, and take in the town’s relaxed rhythm. I found myself drawn back to this path every day—sometimes for people-watching, sometimes just to sit and listen to the water. It’s a gentle reminder that not every holiday moment needs to be packed with plans.
If you’re craving a little excitement, Puerto Pollensa’s bay is a playground for watersports lovers. With calm conditions and plenty of sunshine, it’s the perfect spot to try something new—whether that’s stand-up paddleboarding, windsurfing, or even paragliding for a bird’s-eye view of the bay (a personal highlight if you’re up for the thrill!).
For something a little more relaxed, kayaking along the coastline offers a peaceful way to explore hidden coves and enjoy the scenery from the water. There’s a great mix of family-friendly options and adrenaline-fuelled adventures, so whether you’re dipping your toes in for the first time or you’re already hooked on water-based fun, there’s something here for every energy level.
If beach days are high on your holiday wish list, Puerto Pollensa won’t disappoint. The town’s main beach—Port de Pollença—is hands-down one of the best in northern Mallorca, and once you see it for yourself, you’ll understand why.
This sweeping stretch of sand curves gently around the bay, with shallow, clear turquoise water lapping against its soft golden shore. What makes it really special, though, is the backdrop—the Tramuntana mountains rise up just behind the coastline, creating a dramatic contrast between sea and stone that’s pretty unforgettable. It’s the kind of beach where you can easily spend the whole day—lounging, swimming, reading, or just soaking in the view with an ice cream in hand.
What I especially loved about Puerto Pollensa beach is how close it is to the town—you’re never far from a café, a shaded bench, or a spot to grab lunch. And even during busier summer months, the beach feels spacious and relaxed, never overcrowded.
Let’s be real—if you’re after big nights out and pulsing DJ sets, Puerto Pollensa might not be your scene. But if your idea of the perfect evening involves a glass of local wine, gentle music, and watching the sky shift colours over the bay, then this town delivers in spades.
The nightlife here is laid-back and low-key, which honestly suited me perfectly. There’s a string of bars and pubs lining the seafront, especially around the marina, where you can enjoy a drink with a view. It’s all about atmosphere here—think candle-lit tables, live acoustic sets, and the sound of the waves in the background.
If you wander up to Puerto Pollensa’s main square, you’ll find it comes alive in a more subtle, buzzing way as the night unfolds. Locals and visitors spill out onto terraces, and there’s always a friendly, welcoming vibe. It’s the kind of place where you might plan for “just one drink” and end up staying all night chatting with fellow travellers and friendly bar owners.
I was genuinely impressed by the range and quality of restaurants and eateries here. From family-run tapas bars to Michelin-recommended spots, there’s something for every taste—and dietary preference too, with vegan and vegetarian optionsreadily available. One of my favourite evenings was spent at Restaurant 1929, tucked along the Pine Walk. The food was incredible—rich, flavourful, and clearly crafted with care—and the view over the bay at sunset made it even more special.
Another standout was La Terrassa, which combines romantic ambience with truly exceptional cuisine. Think grilled seafood, delicate Mallorcan wines, and desserts that are far too good to share. Dining in Puerto Pollensa isn’t just a meal—it’s an experience. The kind that lingers in your memory long after the holiday’s over.
Villa Cien 32 is a homely and comforting modern villa offering unrivalled access to the harbour of Puerto Pollensa, which is within walking distance. Sleeping up to 10 guests in 5 bedrooms, it's in a relaxing setting situated in a small residential area, and features its own heated outdoor pool, garden, and children’s playroom.
Each offering its own unique attractions, sights, and atmosphere, both Alcúdia and Puerto Pollensa are spectacular North Mallorca destinations worthy of a visit during your next trip.
Depending on what you enjoy most on holiday, whether you’re a sun-seeking beach lover, an active wilderness explorer, or a history buff, we hope this guide gives you the insight you need into these two equally lovely destinations to help you decide which is the right fit for you.
If you’ve decided whether you’re visiting Alcúdia or Puerto Pollensa and you’re now looking for a place to stay, here at Vida Villas we offer a wide selection of rental properties in both Puerto Pollensa and Alcúdia.
However, should you still be unsure of where to visit, you can find the perfect place to stay between both of these Mallorcan favourites on our website. Alternatively, contact our team, we’ll be happy to find the best property for you.
